Sulat.com / Writing on AIThursday, November 19, 2026
Policy & Society/19 November 2026

Cloudflare CEO says Quad9 leaving France will cost lives; its DNS service ends 24 November

Matthew Prince says Quad9's withdrawal will get people killed. Quad9 says a Paris court's blocking order forces it to stop serving French users on 24 November, and its post doesn't say how it will cut them off.

Glossy 3D magenta Quad9 9 in a data centre aisle, blue, white and red cables running towards a glowing open exit door.

At a glance

  • Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince said on X on 18 November that people will die because Quad9 is leaving France, and blamed French copyright enforcers and the courts behind them.
  • Quad9 says it will stop serving France on 24 November after a Paris court ordered it to block domains for the broadcaster beIN or pay €1,000 a day.
  • Quad9 says it keeps no user records and so can't tell who is in France, and that blocking the domains for everyone would apply a French ruling worldwide.
  • Cloudflare says Quad9's French users include government bodies, schools, hospitals and utilities, and that Cisco has already withdrawn OpenDNS from France and Portugal.
  • Cloudflare says it has never blocked sites through its 1.1.1.1 resolver and has appealed a Belgian order that would penalise it from early January 2027.

Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince says people will die when Quad9, the free public DNS service, stops serving France on 24 November. He made the claim on X on 18 November, sharing Cloudflare’s blog post on the withdrawal, and blamed “France’s copyright cops and the courts that enable them.”

Quad9 is a Swiss non-profit that runs the public resolver at 9.9.9.9. A resolver is the service that turns a website name into the numeric address your device connects to. Quad9 announced on 22 October that it will leave France after a Paris court ruled against it the day before in a case brought by the sports broadcaster beIN.

What Prince and Cloudflare say

Prince wrote that it’s impossible to know which critical systems Quad9 or any other resolver are built into, and that some are about to stop working. His post doesn’t name one. Cloudflare’s post, which it shared on X before his, gives the reasoning: it says Quad9 is used in France by government bodies, educational institutions, hospitals and utilities, and that Quad9 has no way to notify them, so “their Internet will fail with no explanation” if they don’t switch resolver in time.

Cloudflare adds that the problem is worse for devices such as security systems or thermostats that are hardwired to Quad9’s resolver. It says fixing those “may be slow or even impossible.” Cloudflare also runs a rival public resolver, 1.1.1.1.

What the court ordered

beIN asserts that the domains infringe its rights to sports broadcasts, Quad9 says in its announcement. On 13 May the Paris court ordered Quad9 to block access from France to six domain names, a list that grew to 58, according to KontorBund’s reading of the judgment. Reclaim The Net reports that the same order also went to Google and to Whalebone, the operator of the DNS4EU resolver.

On 21 October the court set a penalty of €1,000 a day for not complying, far below the €580,000 a day beIN had sought, Quad9 says. Quad9 says the blocking requirement ends on 14 November, which puts its estimate of the penalty at €24,000 before legal costs, and that an appeal is pending.

Key-number card: beIN asked €580,000 a day, court ordered €1,000 a day, €24,000 total by Quad9's estimate, about 20 other French suits pending.
beIN asked for €580,000 a day; the court ordered €1,000, and about 20 more suits are pending.

Why Quad9 won’t block

Quad9 says it can’t tell which of its users are in France, because it keeps no user records and requires no sign-up. Adding the domains to its global malware blocklist would satisfy the order, it says, but would apply a French ruling to every user worldwide, and it won’t do that.

Quad9 also says geographic blocking has already cost it. In a German case brought by Sony Music, it says, it blocked by location, the plaintiff reached the content through a VPN, and the court fined it for contempt. It eventually won that case, after several years and six figures in costs. Quad9 says about 20 other lawsuits in France seek blocks on hundreds more names, and that it can’t survive the penalties from those.

Four-step chain: Paris court orders blocking, Quad9 can't tell who is in France, block for everyone or leave, service ends 24 November.
Quad9 says it can’t tell who is in France, so the choice was to block for everyone or leave.

Who loses service

Quad9 published a partial list of French networks it sees traffic from. It includes DINUM, the prime minister’s digital directorate; EDF; SNCF; the research network RENATER; the Marseille public hospital group AP-HM; and France Télévisions. Quad9 says hundreds more French networks use it and that all of them lose service on 24 November.

The list names networks, not the systems running on them. Quad9’s post also doesn’t say how it will cut off French users when it keeps no record of where they are.

Where Cloudflare stands

Cloudflare says Cisco has already withdrawn its OpenDNS resolver from France and Portugal, and temporarily from Belgium. It says a Belgian court has ordered Cloudflare, Google and Cisco to block sites through their public resolvers or face substantial penalties from early January 2027, something Cloudflare says it has never done, and that all three have appealed. It hopes for a ruling before the end of the year.

TorrentFreak reports that on 17 September the Paris court rejected a request by the broadcaster Canal+ for penalties of €50,000 per site per day against Cloudflare. The court accepted that Cloudflare blocks the sites through its content delivery network, not through 1.1.1.1. TorrentFreak, citing Cloudflare’s transparency report, says Cloudflare geoblocked 1,238 domains in France that way in the second half of 2025.

What French users can do

Quad9 says it hopes 30 days is enough time for people to switch resolvers, and that it expects its notice won’t reach everyone. If 9.9.9.9 appears in the DNS settings of a router, phone or office network in France, it needs changing before 24 November. Devices with the address built in need checking too.

Checklist: look for 9.9.9.9, switch before 24 November, check hardwired devices, nobody will warn you because Quad9 keeps no user list.
If 9.9.9.9 is in your settings, switch before 24 November; Quad9 can’t warn you.

Quad9 says it will keep contesting the ruling and the other French cases in court. Its service in France ends on Tuesday 24 November.


Discover more from Sulat AI & Tech News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.